HOME Quality Enhancement Plan SACS Topics Comprehensive Standards Page
 


TTU Original Statement:
 

3.6  Educational Programs:  Graduate and Post-Baccalaureate Professional
     
3.6.1  The institution’s post-baccalaureate professional degree programs, and its master’s and
doctoral degree programs are progressively more advanced in academic content than

undergraduate programs.
     
ţ Compliance                     *  Partial Compliance                  * Non-Compliance 
     
  Narrative: 
     
 

Texas Tech University is in compliance with Comprehensive Standard 3.6.1.

The prologue to the catalog section on Graduate Studies and Research states: 

Graduate study is much more than a continuation of undergraduate work. It is distinguished by the spirit of inquiry and the desire to increase human knowledge. Graduate study should be contemplated, therefore, only by students who have demonstrated in their undergraduate programs unusual intellectual ability and the capacity for independent thought and investigation. (p. 57) (http://www.depts.ttu.edu/officialpublications/catalog/GradSchool.html#About)

 

This statement reflects an expectation on the part of the Graduate School that students will be required to meet higher standards than undergraduates, especially with respect to the ability to learn independently and to think creatively.  

Ultimately, it is the Graduate School and the individual colleges and departments of the university that determine the content and level of difficulty of post-graduate courses. The Graduate Studies and Research section of the catalog notes repeatedly that graduate work expectations exceed those of the undergraduate level. For example, under Prerequisites for a Graduate Major, students are informed: “For a graduate major, an applicant must have completed, or must take, sufficient undergraduate work to ensure adequate background for successful graduate work in the proposed field.” (p. 64) (http://www.depts.ttu.edu/officialpublications/catalog/GRADEnrollment.html) In a subsequent note under Prerequisites for the Master’s Degree students are advised that “[a] substantial body of undergraduate work in the major subject and considerable breadth of background are essential for graduate study.” 

Graduate students are not allowed to count undergraduate courses toward their degree; however, undergraduate students who have at least a B (3.00) average in their major subject, who are within 12 hours of graduation, and who apply for permission through the Graduate School, may enroll in courses for graduate credit and may apply up to 12 hours of such credit toward a graduate degree. (p. 64) (http://www.depts.ttu.edu/officialpublications/catalog/GRADEnrollment.html) These requirements suggest a clear distinction in level of difficulty between graduate and undergraduate courses. 

Courses offered for graduate credit must be approved within the college in which they originate and also be approved by the Graduate School. The Graduate Council of the Graduate School, a rotating body of elected faculty who represent each of the colleges and schools in the university that offer courses for graduate credit (the exception is the Honors College), has the responsibility for approving all graduate programs and courses (http://www.depts.ttu.edu/officialpublications/catalog/GRADCouncil.html). This approval process also helps to insure that graduate programs and courses are substantially more advanced in both academic content and also in their expectations that students will be able to learn independently and apply what they learn to formulating and conducting independent research within the context of the discipline in which they are working.  

Finally, most professional graduate programs and many non-professional areas are accredited by discipline-specific organizations. (A list of such accrediting organizations is provided at the front of the catalog on p. 2.) (http://www.depts.ttu.edu/officialpublications/catalog/Catalog.html#Expiration) These accrediting agencies also help to insure that graduate education is progressively more advanced than undergraduate programs.

     
     
  COMPLIANCE DOCUMENTATION
  Units:
  Office of the Provost:
    Deans:
      College of Agricultural Sciences & Natural Resources
      College of Architecture
      College of Arts and Sciences
      College of Education
      College of Engineering
      College of Human Sciences
      College of Visual and Performing Arts
      Graduate School
      Honors College
      Law
      Rawls College of Business
    Others:
      Center for Advanced Study of Museum Science and Heritage Management
     
     

 
SACS Off-Site Committee Finding: 

3.6.1     The institution’s post-baccalaureate professional degree programs, and its master’s and doctoral degree programs, are progressively more advanced in academic content than undergraduate programs.   

___       Compliance
_X_      Non-compliance
___       Did not review
 

Comments:   

The institution’s Compliance Certification Report responds to CS 3.6.1, and much of the narrative is adequate.  But there is one part of the standard that is less well supported: “…degree programs … are progressively more advanced….”  The institution did not provide adequate documentation to support this statement.  The on-site committee should spot check courses and programs to assess compliance with this requirement.

  

TTU Response:  

We are supplying a sample of comparable undergraduate and graduate course syllabi from various programs across the campus to support our contention that master’s and doctoral degree courses are progressively more advanced.  

Additional syllabi will be provided for review by the On-Site Committee during their visit to the TTU campus. 

The graduate program review process and the graduate course review process also contribute to insuring that Master’s level and doctoral level courses are progressively more advanced than undergraduate courses. The graduate program review process is available at http://www.depts.ttu.edu/gradschool/review_guidelines.htm. This process provides for peer review of all graduate departments and programs at 6-year intervals. Graduate program reviews are on file in the Graduate School offices (Holden Hall 01), where they may be reviewed by members of the On-Site Committee upon request. 

The process for approving graduate courses begins at the department level, where courses are proposed and approved by department faculty. From the department courses move to a college-level approval process. Unlike undergraduate courses, graduate courses also must be approved by the Graduate Council, a body comprised of graduate faculty representatives from each college (three from the College of Arts and Sciences, representing sciences, social sciences, and humanities) who are elected to three-year terms by their colleagues. Current membership on the Graduate Council and council minutes are available on line at (http://www.depts.ttu.edu/gradschool/gcmembers.htm). The final levels of approval are the Academic Council (provost level) and the Texas Higher Education Coordinating Board. This rigorous approval process helps to insure that graduate courses are appropriately advanced and rigorous for their degree level.

 

  List of Sample Syllabi
   
COURSE NO. DEPT/AREA COURSE DESCRIPTION
ACCT 2300 Accounting Financial Accounting
ACCT 2301 Accounting Managerial Accounting
ACCT 5401 Accounting Financial and Managerial Accounting
ANTH 3342/5343 Anthropology Prehistory of the American Southwest
ART  4322 Art Experimental Painting
ART 5322 Art Graduate Painting
BIOL 4305 Biology Organic Evolution
BIOL 5305 Biology Organic Evolution
C E 4343 Civil Engineering Design of Concrete Structures
C E 5343 Civil Engineering Design of Concrete Structures
CHEM 4310 Chemistry Polymer Chemistry
CHEM 5310 Chemistry Polymer Chemistry
COMS 3313 Communication Studies Persuasion
COMS 5313 Communication Studies Theories of Persuasion
ECO 4305 Economics Econometrics
ECO 5314 Economics Econometrics
ENGL 3325 English Contemporary American Literature
ENGL 3365 English Professional Report Writing
ENGL 5324 English Studies in 20th Century American Literature
ENGL 5373 English Technical Manuals
ESS 3301 Exercise & Sport Sciences Biomechanics
ESS 5306 Exercise & Sport Sciences Biomechanics of Exercise & Sport
ISQS 3348 ISQS Database Management Systems
ISQS 6338 ISQS Information & Systems Concepts in Org.
MGT 3376 Management Organizational Behavior
MGT 5371 Management Managing Organizational Behavior and Design
MATH 4310 Mathematics Introduction to Numerical Analysis I
MATH 5334 Mathematics Numerical Methods for Engineers
MUAP 3303 Music Undergraduate Vocal Literature
MUAP 5302 Music Graduate Vocal Literature
MUAP 3303/5302 Music MUAP 3303 and 5302 Comparison
PHIL 3301 Philosophy Classical Greek Philosophy
PHIL 5301 Philosophy Studies in Greek Philosophy
PHYS 4307 Physics Introduction to Quantum Mechanics
PHYS 5301 Physics Quantum Mechanics I
POLS 3361 Political Science International Politics
POLS 5360 Political Science International Relations Theory
PSY 3401 Psychology Research Methods
PSY 5345 Psychology Research Seminar in Clinical Psychology
SOC 3394 Sociology Contemporary Sociological Theories
SOC 5303 Sociology Contemporary Sociological Theories
THA 3335 Theatre   Script Analysis
THA 5300 Theatre   Dramatic Analysis
       
       
Click here to return to the main TTU Certification of Compliance Page

These web pages are best viewed using Microsoft Internet Explorer
The documents may appear distorted when viewed using another web browser.

Copyright 2002 Texas Tech University | All Rights Reserved | TTU Privacy Policy | Texas Public Information Act
Maintained by: Department of Institutional Research and Information Management | Contact: Webmaster
Last updated:  Tuesday, September 09, 2008 11:35 AM CST.
TTU is not responsible for the content of external sources.